Where’s the bottom?
On Martin Luther King Jr. Day, Embrace’s President and CEO, Imari Paris Jeffries, Ph.D., said the following in an article he penned for USA TODAY about the killing of Renee Good by an ICE officer in Minneapolis: “Public lynching will now be televised. And America has learned how to watch.”
Less than a week later, we witnessed another.
Alex Pretti, a registered nurse and legal observer, was publicly executed on camera on Saturday—the second person to die by the Department of Homeland Security’s hand in Minnesota this month. He was holding a phone in his hand, his legally carried firearm holstered at his side. His last act: rushing to the aid of a woman being beaten by federal agents, shielding her from their assault. He paid for his good deed with his life.
In the aftermath, a familiar refrain popped up again:
We’ve reached an “unprecedented” moment in American history.
Never before have agents of the state so brazenly assaulted United States citizens, indiscriminately snatching them off the streets or killing them in cold blood if they did not comply.
Not even Bull Connor, the villain of the Edmund Pettus Bridge in Selma, Alabama, ever did something as cruel as those ICE agents.
This is something out of Nazi Germany, not the United States of America.
This isn’t the America we recognize.
But here’s the thing. To many of us, this moment isn’t unprecedented.
Many folks just don’t remember what America is and always has been.
That’s why there’s no last straw. No bottom. No magical button that will make us change our ways.
We’ve lived through Trayvon Martin. Michael Brown. Eric Garner. Sandra Bland. Philando Castile. George Floyd. Breonna Taylor.
We saw the pictures of Black people being sprayed mercilessly with fire hoses, attacked by dogs and beaten with clubs on the road to Selma. We remember the open casket of Emmett Till, and the lifeless bodies of Martin Luther King Jr., Malcolm X, Medgar Evers and Fred Hampton. And that doesn’t even cover the atrocities for which there were no cameras or photos.
The reason this moment feels unprecedented to some is because of who the violence is happening to now: the people the state is supposed to protect, not just those it was designed to oppress.